Ask HN: How did the industry settle on weekly limits?

I understand that the cheap compute ride wouldn't last forever but something that feels somewhat unique seems to have come about from all of this AI belt tightening.

Weekly Limits

This policy seemed to come from almost nowhere but was quickly adopted across many products. Cutting off access for 25% of the time based product you've paid for feels like it is just incompatible with a subscription at the core conceptual level. Cooldown times and over-use back-offs are nothing new but there is a drastic difference in tone from 5 hours to 5-7 days.

I'm at a loss to see how this became an acceptable practice with the most common answer being "Buy more subs"

3 points | by saratogacx 12 hours ago

4 comments

  • tughvn 9 hours ago
    It's probably a capacity problem, but we need to speak up for something better.
    [-]
    • saratogacx 4 hours ago
      That is very likely one of the biggest drivers but there's a misalignment. Tasks take minutes to hours, so why such an outsized block for the system to calm down. Taking away this much availability used to be in the realms of abuse bans, not day to day operation.
  • tkiolp4 11 hours ago
    Just cancel your subscription.
    [-]
    • saratogacx 4 hours ago
      Yes, I'm aware with what options I have, they've been detailed quite thoroughly in the many other threads on this topic. The question is about understanding the trend of week long cut-offs.
  • dbeyzade 10 hours ago
    "Weekly caps feel like a psychological nudge toward higher tiers rather than a genuine resource constraint. The industry collectively normalized it because it works."
    [-]
    • saratogacx 3 hours ago
      This feels like it is way more on point than I'd want it to be but at the same time it's broadcasting that you'll get continually enshittified with us so don't invest too much in being a long term customer. People don't really like feeling like they're being ripped or sold a bill of goods that won't deliver and that experience follows them when they get to make bigger decisions with bigger wallets at stake.
  • bigyabai 12 hours ago
    You can still buy tokens direct from the API. The subscription model is not much more than a glorified paid trial.
    [-]
    • saratogacx 3 hours ago
      I have other services I can turn to so I currently just switch providers but a glorified paid trial is pretty unsatisfying if the experience is being cut off for weeks at a time. API's don't go that route now but neither did subs (although I see the big difference in motivation to not cut-off api users).