I spent 50 hours drawing a line graph

(dougmacdowell.com)

113 points | by dougdude3339 2 days ago

16 comments

  • Daub 3 minutes ago
    I teach digital art and am also a painter. When I was a student I loved filling sketchbooks with drawings - like a collection of ideas. To a large degree my web bookmarks and screen grab library have taken over this function. That being said, if I want to quickly communicate visual ideas to students or craftsmen I much prefer a paper and pencil. It feels so much more nuanced, comfortable and expressive.
  • card_zero 54 minutes ago
    This should be a competitive sport, like gymnastics. He's attempting the bevel! With extra-wide lines! Very ambitious, but unfortunately he often fails to stick the corner alignments, the bevel distances are poorly controlled, and the data is unsuitably spiky for that choice of line joint. 7/10.
    • jansan 10 minutes ago
      When you say bevel, do you mean the miter limit?
    • matja 46 minutes ago
      I loved hearing this comment in my mind :)
  • apwheele 34 minutes ago
    You should add in Calvin Schmid's Handbook of Graphic Presentation into your list Doug -- https://archive.org/details/HandbookOfGraphicPresentation/pa...

    Unfortunately I do not see specific discussion of how to make the lines a consistent thickness. It does have notes on how to sharpen your pencil and how to use a carpenters spline to draw smooth curves though.

  • jstummbillig 2 hours ago
    > A professional draftsman of the 1920's may cringe at the imperfections in my line graph above. They can suck it.

    I am willing to suck it but the kerning is still killing me. (I love everything about this btw)

  • max-ch 46 minutes ago
    Fantastic read!

    In the mid-2010s, I was interning at the German federal statistical office. Some of the team assistants were there since the 1980s/90s and had still learnt to use those tools as part of their vocational training. They also showed me the tools and the instructions for drawing exactly aligned tables by hand and the resulting bound sets of tables with hundreds of pages. Completely mind-boggling how much time they must have spent on a single project, now all automated away.

  • yvdriess 2 hours ago
    And here I thought drawing graphs in TikZ was doing it manually.

    Love the article, this is why I browse HN.

  • pram 2 hours ago
    They look really good. I really enjoy looking at midcentury engineering charts/diagrams and stuff like jeppesen charts. NASA has a lot of good ones. The way the text looks, the line economy, the general aesthetic. Well worth the effort imo!
  • codeduck 39 minutes ago
    This is my favourite kind of post here
    • Biganon 26 minutes ago
      Same. Any kind of hyper fixation is infinitely more interesting than AI bullshit.
  • flir 20 minutes ago
    Heh. Which if y'all borrowed the Tufte book?

    It's ok, I can wait...

  • dougdude3339 2 days ago
    What's been more interesting to me lately than using software to design data visualizations is learning to draw data by hand. It's a time consuming process but incredibly rewarding. The feeling of erasing graphite to reveal clean, crisp lines is something that software cannot recreate.
    • otherme123 2 hours ago
      What do you use to erase pencil? The words "Using an eraser and a light touch" suggest a gum or a vynil eraser. I make a ball with the kneaded eraser and roll it with the palm against the paper.
  • bananaflag 48 minutes ago
    What I'm curious now is how one could use software (even PowerPoint) to make graphs that replicate that handmade aesthetic.
  • petesergeant 12 minutes ago
    Does he explain what the red dots in the titles of his work are meant to be? Possibly I didn’t read carefully enough
  • satisfice 1 hour ago
    It’s nice to see something on HN that isn’t about writing a prompt so that you can pretend to work.
  • m_m_carvalho 14 minutes ago
    [flagged]
  • mrstorm 2 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • jdw64 1 hour ago
    [dead]