The 98% Slot Machine: How Paid Advertising Became an Extraction Tax

(globalcommercegraph.com)

104 points | by dev1one1 3 hours ago

19 comments

  • hatthew 1 hour ago
    This analogy doesn't hold at all. Casinos are engineered for the house to win and the customer to lose because the casino is paying the customer directly. They are disincentivized to let the customer win. If the customer always won, the casino goes out of business very quickly.

    Ad auctions are completely different, since they are just a marketplace. A customer's (advertiser's) win comes from a third party, and the point of the ad platform is to connect that third party to the customer. The ad platform would love to be able to make every single customer win all the time. Although, if they did that, it would create a lot more demand and even out the ROI with increased ad prices. But that's not the "evil ad platform" engineering the customers to always lose in the way casinos do, that's simply basic supply/demand economics.

    COI disclaimer: My current job is a small part of an ads platform on a website you have heard of. I dislike ads but realize they are a necessity for running some parts of the internet.

    • mangoceylon 1 hour ago
      Yea, I also work in ads and the article doesn't make sense at all. A way bigger factor than anything mentioned in this article is simply what you as an advertiser can afford as a CAC (cost to acquire a customer). There are some advertisers who are selling low cost/low repeat products that advertising is nearly impossible to make profitable. Meanwhile, other advertisers are selling high cost/high repeat products to that same person. The latter can afford to price the former out of ad inventory.

      Many companies are spending significant amounts of money (many millions) and not even telling the advertising platforms the actual revenue they generated from the ads, just the number of "leads" or "customers" because they are paranoid about the very thing in the article (which I don't actually believe to be true anyway).

      • davidfischer 41 minutes ago
        > Meanwhile, other advertisers are selling high cost/high repeat products to that same person. The latter can afford to price the former out of ad inventory.

        This is correct. The best advertisers are setting the floor prices for ads within their niche. This is why StackOverflow, before their fall, had just a few advertisers like Google, IBM/RedHat, and Azure. Those advertisers were willing to buy pretty much the whole inventory at a price a startup focusing on say a single niche SO tag couldn't compete with.

        Disclosure: Work on an ad startup I helped build. I talk to over a dozen advertisers every day. We have similar problems with advertisers trying to buy most/all of our inventory and we explicitly cap the max percentage we'll sell to any one advertiser.

        • PaulHoule 30 minutes ago
          In the 2000s my political activism and business involvements had me in contact with people involved in local newspaper and radio ads in my community.

          I always had the impression that there is a tranche of advertiser who is "made of money" who doesn't care what ads cost and... that person drives the market.

          For instance in my town there is one guy who owns all the new card dealerships in town and he saturates the airwaves, I think because he loves to hear his name on the radio. For the rest of us it just reminds us that the next time we buy a car we're going to drive 50 miles to a town where one guy doesn't own all the new car dealerships.

          If a radio ad costs him $20 I am sure he gets at least $20 of pleasure from hearing his name and he makes monopoly profits so he can afford it!

          A similar story was that a tiny ad in the local newspaper cost $100 a day and it was stupendously difficult to make a case that this was worth it for most small businesses, especially when you could get a storefront for that much or hire a part-timer. I'd talk to people who sold ads for the paper and they told me, "we tell them that their customers will think they went out of business if they stop advertising!"

          Some of the rapid collapse of "old media" was that the foundations of it were pretty rotten and people didn't see the value they were getting out of it and were ready to pull out of it as soon as they could.

      • jolt42 16 minutes ago
        Is this why during a show I'll see the SAME ad multiple times? Like if i ignored it the first time, why would I care the second time.
        • hatthew 13 minutes ago
          Some ads are designed for awareness, rather than for direct action. Repetition creates a stronger long term memory.
      • Scaled 49 minutes ago
        I'm in the paranoid camp. I've always wondered who in their right mind sends profit data upstream when it's exactly what the networks need to push margins down. Maybe Google and the others don't actually use that for ill intent, but they don't exactly have trustworthy reputations. If it came out tomorrow that they were using the data to inflate their margin, no one would be surprised.
      • vanviegen 49 minutes ago
        I think you misunderstood the article. They are not claiming the ad platform is actively calibrating prices to take everything you can spare, but that that is an inherent result of the bidding war, at least for product categories where products are at least a little bit interchangable.
        • hatthew 4 minutes ago
          The article very heavily implies that ad platforms are actively bad. It draws comparisons to casinos, including explicitly saying that ad platforms are engineered to act the same. It says "we never blame the auction house" in a way that is obviously implying we should blame the auction house.
    • danielmarkbruce 1 hour ago
      You have picked one dimension, incentives, and say the analogy doesn't work because on that dimension it's different. Analogies aren't supposed to be exactly the same.

      The point of the analogy stands - most players using paid advertising can't win. They don't realize the entire structure of the market makes it close to impossible for them to win. Google (and a small number of others) have an extremely strong position in what is effectively the distribution channel for a lot of businesses, and a pricing mechanism which enables them to take a giant chunk of economics of the transaction.

    • uptrails 1 hour ago
      It's an entirely AI-generated article. There's almost certainly no human making a good-faith argument here. You're wasting your time arguing with an LLM, which is a pretty good illustration of why I think we should be shunning such content. Only so many hours in a day.
      • VBprogrammer 31 minutes ago
        What makes you say it is LLM generated? Having to sift though LLM generated content is part of my day job these days but I don't recognise this as LLM generated. It has a voice and a thread running through it which I've never seen an LLM manage.

        It might be a bad analogy and you may not agree with the message but that was a thing well before LLMs entered the everyday vernacular.

      • gdulli 1 hour ago
        I'm now shunning any domain I don't recognize and de facto upranking any domain I recognize from being around for more than five years. Which is unfortunate because not every old domain deserves a positive reputation, they've only gained that by default relative to most of what's "published" today.
      • hatthew 1 hour ago
        Oh I'm very aware of that. I'm not trying to arguing against the article. I'm trying to inform the dozens of people who are upvoting this post and implicitly think it makes any semblance of a good point.
    • bix6 1 hour ago
      > I dislike ads but realize they are a necessity for running some parts of the internet.

      Can you expand on this? Why are they necessary for some parts?

      • edoceo 1 hour ago
        People who believe ads are necessary have an underlying assumption that commerce is also a requirement. It's a shaky basis, and leads to a bunch of other messy things (ads to demographic to profiles to tracking)
      • hatthew 55 minutes ago
        Not strictly necessary, but functionally necessary. Many websites provide services that are expensive to run and can't be funded by other products from the company, so the website itself has to be profitable. I'm not convinced that these websites (e.g. most social media) are societally necessary, but I don't see any scenario where they continue to exist without advertising (barring extreme measures such as government funding).
    • analyst74 26 minutes ago
      It's like casino hosting poker games, like a tournament. Between the players (advertisers) it's zero sum, because there are just so much money (end user attention and money), and house (ad platform) takes a cut in the proceeds.
  • hackthemack 1 hour ago
    I use to think we lived in an enlightened age, where we have now learned that we need to use scientific reasoning and analysis to make decisions. It is what lifted us up from superstition and folk tales.

    But society, still, collectively, falls for snake oil, over and over again.

    This topic was talked about in 2019. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21465873

    Freakanomics did a great podcast about if Internet Advertising actually works. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47906485

    Anyone that has an interest in the topic should listen (or read) about what Steve Tadelis did in the 2012 timeframe. He was an economics professor at the University of California, Berkeley, and then worked at eBay, where he led the famous experiment on Google ad effectiveness.

    • pixl97 1 hour ago
      People are born in ignorance. Reason takes energy. Nature optimizes for energy efficiency.

      This is likely a hole us meat puppets can never crawl out of. Any moment we stop spending energy to climb out, we're sliding down the ant lion nest to ignorance.

    • doctorpangloss 1 hour ago
      i can't square away all of this with the simple math that if you make a product that makes sense for online advertising, you make boatloads of money by using online ads, and make less as more people compete in it.

      this is true of GLP1 ads and for many, many subscription services like video streaming.

      i'm not sure it's about falling for something so much as it is that people who like, sell products through amazon, well, they are fucked no matter what.

    • pfisch 1 hour ago
      The average IQ is 100. These expectations are totally unreasonable.

      Anyone with an IQ in that range or lower absolutely needs a reliable source to just tell them what to do and how to live.

      Social media and weaponized right wing "news" have set all those reliable sources on fire.

      • PaulHoule 1 hour ago
        The trouble is people lacking wisdom more than people lacking intelligence.

        Like lately I have been going to talks by Native Americans whose spirituality is rooted in place, relationships, commitment and all that

        https://americanindian.si.edu/environment/pdf/01_02_Thanksgi...

        and that somebody is looking seven generations (or even a seventh of a generation) ahead seems so strange in 2026 when so many people think they can enjoy being poor forever (like billions of years) if they don't manage to pound out 15 ai slop blog posts to prove to everyone else that they know where ai is going.

  • jwpapi 2 minutes ago
    That’s just victimhood mentality. There are tons of examples of companies printing with ads. I’m not saying that there aren’t players that play net-negative games. And those playing hurt everyone but the advertising sellers, but the game is not fundamentally flawed.
  • bearjaws 1 hour ago
    I don't really think this is true, as if advertising didn't work people wouldn't use it.

    That being said, there is something to be said about how extractive it has become.

    It used to be you ran a TV ad, and if you made a great ad, you got amazing ROI, you were rewarded for being clever.

    Now, it's all captured algorithmically, there are no "great ads", you can only have good ads or bad ads. They know full well if your ad is great then they can charge you whatever they want, inevitably making your ROI only "good enough". Sure go to another platform where the algorithm will price you out eventually.

    Look at Him & Hers / Ro / GoodRx / etc. They basically take every dollar they make and throw it into advertising, it's the only way to stay relevant.

  • PotenRoyal 1 hour ago
    The gambling analogy doesn’t quite hold here. Gambling is a zero sum game. Advertising is not a zero sum game. There is room for both sides to walk away with gains from trade.
    • InsideOutSanta 1 hour ago
      The article explains why that isn't the case: it's because advertisers (Google's clients who run ads) are competing with each other to push the cost of advertising up to the point where the cost of an ad and the value it provided reach a rough equilibrium.
      • dghlsakjg 16 minutes ago
        > advertisers (Google's clients who run ads) are competing with each other to push the cost of advertising up to the point where the cost of an ad and the value it provided reach a rough equilibrium.

        Yup. That's econ 101, except that the price you pay is not the value you would have gotten, it is the price one bid increment higher than the value your competition would have gotten/was willing to pay. You can still have consumer surplus on your side of the trade as long as the sale is a proxy or vickery auction - like most ad sales are.

      • feifan 1 hour ago
        this is competition, not gambling.
        • nkmnz 1 hour ago
          And in economic theory, perfect competition drives the margin to zero. The gambling part is not explaining that theory, but rather the effect on human behavior when the short term results hover around that zero margin line.
          • PaulHoule 27 minutes ago
            The margin for the marginal participant! The more profitable participants will still make a profit. You need some argument like "the profitable participants are going to seek to expand their business until it isn't profitable anymore" to truly eradicate profits in theory.

            If you look at the oil business, for instance, the Saudis have a much lower cost than anybody else in the business so they could be profitably selling oil in a world where everybody else is losing money.

        • InsideOutSanta 47 minutes ago
          The gambling part is how the competition between advertisers is implemented.
    • jamedjo 1 hour ago
      It's often constant sum, because in ads can move sales between organisations instead of creating value.

      With the automated bidder maximising ad prices for shareholder returns it can become zero sum equivalent. Every gain is matched by a loss elsewhere.

      This changes if ads are creating new demand, or if consumers are getting value they otherwise wouldn't have found. But in many markets that won't be the case.

      This means is often

    • eesmith 1 hour ago
      That wasn't the analogy. It's gambling in the sense "the house always wins".

      It's not a simple "both sides" issue - the scenario has multiple sides. You find a good keyword, someone finds you, you both benefit. Great!

      Then a third party finds and uses your strategy, and bids higher in the ad auction. This reduces profits. As more parties join in, the profits decrease.

      The thesis is that those profits don't simply go to zero, but can actually result in a net loss. In the meanwhile, those higher bids end up as profits for the auction house.

      • PotenRoyal 1 hour ago
        Uh, yeah the house always wins because it is zero sum. In a competitive market there is gains from trades. Rational actors can drive consumer and producer surplus to zero but once rational actors won't continue to buy at a loss.

        I'm picking on the gambling analogy. It is wrong.

        I agree with the general thesis of the article.

        • eesmith 5 minutes ago
          Ahh, I see. I've only dealt with zero sum games with two parties.

          I was under the impression that most auction houses are not zero-sum games. The auction house makes a profit, but the buyer and seller also win.

  • steeleyespan 1 hour ago
    An AI written article with a bad analogy
  • conformist 1 hour ago
    Psychological elements aside, this sort of misses that goods and services require multiple inputs from different counterparties (or different markets) that have different pricing power (some of which might be close to monopolies). It’s implausible that whenever there is one monopoly seller anywhere that all added economic value (or more than all, as in the article??) has to go to that one.

    If I have to necessarily buy ads from google and water from the local water company, where does the economic value go in equilibrium? Clearly not all to the water company and not all just to google.

  • dzink 1 hour ago
    Gambling, advertising, trading, and AI have one thing in common: if you don’t do well it’s your fault. You didn’t prompt right, or target the right audience, or you don’t have the right harness, and the only way to remedy is always to spend more money.

    The only way to keep out of those traps is to have real metrics of your own and benchmarks of your own. Performance changes over time so you can never trust the current state will continue.

  • octoberfranklin 7 minutes ago
    A slot machine knows how much income the user is receiving because the slot machine hands it to them.

    But in this model, the small business's revenue stream isn't (in most case) something that the ad networks can see.

  • vgeek 2 hours ago
    The whole ecosystem is extractive with the goal of improving quarterly earnings by removing control from the people spending the money. Online ads started out being trackable and much higher ROI than traditional media. Then they ran traditional media out of business while continously raising their own rates (opaque quality score, nebulous targeting options) and then go even further, essentially stealing publishers' content for their own walled garden models.
  • larodi 1 minute ago
    So glad not having to look at this damn dashboard and all its myriad of tools, interconnects and whatnots, which even claim to be able to attribute a sale to some bizarre ins and outs of the search. Of course if all cookies, tags, and pixels that you have to install beforehand work. And also validations, and confirmations, legal checks, etc, etc. It reaaally is a giant slot machine. Really, first you have to be very lucky to get an actually good connectivity of all the needed info, and then you need to see Google in its lucky day actually driving this traffic that your struggling business so much needs.

    As my godfather put it once - dude, you better give $10 each customer to come and buy, rather than spend $420 to get three. It will work better.

    I very much hope this all dies for good with AI, something tells me we're in for v2 where all the bullshit is injected into LLM streams, and then other local LLMs would need to adblock it. Sad story. Not the internet I got fascinated about as a kid, tempting to attribute it to age, but there was surely more awe and fun in it than this never-ending slop of irrelevancy, and I'm not even talking AI.

  • stevage 1 hour ago
    They do not present any data at all to support their 98% figure.
  • scotty79 23 minutes ago
    Business are trees. Customers are sunlight. Advertisements are the trunks.

    Incredibly wasteful and as tall as they can physically be. If trees could talk to each other and decide to limit the heights of the trunks arbitrarily there would be so much energy saved that could be put into seeds and fruit to spread the forest faster.

    But the trees of course can't agree because any defector would gain advantage over the cooperating trees.

    In case of the economy the government should step in and replace the whole advertising industry with a single always up to date catalog of goods and services. If comapnies couldn't get ahead by inflating marketing budgets they would be forced to compete on quality and price instead what would be beneficial for everything including the health of those companies.

  • cm2012 2 hours ago
    It's an auction. It's not a conspiracy.

    Every marketing channel has its pros and cons. Advertising is no exception.

    • datadrivenangel 1 hour ago
      Amazon got fined a bajillion dollars for deciding to add undisclosed reserve prices for their ad auctions. They just decided that too many auctions ended too low, so they added fake reserve prices and just chose what the price would be...
      • Scaled 56 minutes ago
        Google and Meta have also both been caught in advertising shenanigans -- I forget the details but I recall getting some (tiny) class action settlement check.
  • RicoElectrico 2 hours ago
    There's too little discussion out there about how scammy the online advertising is. Wish there was a reckoning.
  • vinyl7 1 hour ago
    Still blows my mind that people pay to advertise to bots. Dead internet theory and all that
    • motionlessveloc 1 hour ago
      "Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.” John Wanamaker (1838-1922)
  • sandworm101 2 hours ago
    I drive by an Ikea on my way to work. They just installed a video wall in view of the highway. It is huge, four stories tall and square. It gets noticed but is not intrusive. It is not animated. In daylight it just looks like a big painting. At night it isn't any brighter than the parking lot around it. Yesterday it was advertising an end table for 65$. This morning it was something with a plant in the background. I actually saw and remember that ad. I almost never see ads on websites and certainly don't remember those I do. But that Ikea wall... THAT I remember.

    Online adds are a fool's errand.

  • thatmf 1 hour ago
    Won't somebody think about the founders??
  • grd_dev 1 hour ago
    [dead]