Anthropic should give stock to Stack Overflow (and OpenAI too)

Anthropic and OpenAI should give Stack Overflow a percentage of their company.

They used all of Stack Overflow's data to train their AI models at the beginning of LLMs without paying for it because it was publicly available online.

ChatGPT and Claude would not exist today without the 24 million coding questions and 36 million answers with code examples included, all created by real humans who took the time to write the questions and answers.

Stack Overflow deserves to be rewarded for making Anthropic and OpenAI such a success.

And all the developers who posted and answered questions on Stack Overflow should be given stock too.

13 points | by thetjmccarty 2 days ago

6 comments

  • charliercrvta 4 hours ago
    Well if they do, they would basically abandon their stance that training on public data is fair use, and that would line up every authors on the internet to demand to be rewarded with the same stock.
  • muzani 1 day ago
    The decline began 6 years ago after the Monica incident. The CEO burned up the community (including Stack Exchange) to get it to IPO. He succeeded.

    They couldn't fix the community, even after establishing a "tiger team" to investigate. It evolved from a community of people who tried to help beginners into a community of bullies. Questions died from the hostility, then answers died. I used to put my top 1% SO karma in my resume, but after a while it became a negative signal, the kind you'd associate with being a reddit mod.

    None of those guys should be getting rich off it. But some did and they should be happy with what they had.

    Most of the solutions from AI today comes from it being trained on the manuals not some "Closed as duplicate" answer on Stack Overflow. There's probably more valid data from reddit than SO in the past 3-4 years.

  • linesofcode 1 day ago
    We’re all standing on somebody’s shoulders, technological advancement of today would not be possible without someone putting in the work yesterday, just like tomorrows achievements will be built on today’s.

    On a more somber note - this is a business, why would a company like stack overflow be rewarded for fumbling the ball so hard when they had all the training data (according to your post).

  • rvz 1 day ago
    No they don't. StackOverflow could have competed and trained a model and done it themselves. But they did not and someone else (Anthropic and OpenAI) did.

    That's that. StackOverflow lost, and that's too bad.

    • thetjmccarty 1 day ago
      I wish they would have.

      It's like Blockbuster vs Netflix all over again. Blockbuster had so much time to create their own Netflix, but didn't.

  • vuggamie 1 day ago
    Why not? VA Linux gave stock to slashdot commenters. They're all in a better place now.
  • SpekCoin 2 hours ago
    [dead]